FreeVector

Assets & Workflow · 14 tools ranked

Best Creative Proofing Software in 2026

Ziflow ranks first in creative proofing software, followed by Filestage and GoVisually. Creative proofing software collects pinned comments and recorded approvals on artwork, video and web pages, so review rounds end with one agreed version.

The top three

How this list is ordered: by our editorial assessment of fit for designers, creators and small to mid-sized creative and marketing teams. Vendors can pay for more visibility; how that works is explained in our disclosure, linked above every ranking. No commission is earned on clicks or purchases, and we do not work as an affiliate.

What is creative proofing software?

Creative proofing software is a review-and-approval platform where designers, editors and marketers upload artwork, video, documents or live web pages and collect comments pinned to the exact spot. Reviewers mark up the file, compare versions and give a recorded approval. Some products also check print details such as barcodes and color separations, or run automated brand checks.

How we ranked these

Most creative teams do not lose time making the work. They lose it chasing feedback that arrives as email replies, chat threads and screenshots with red circles drawn on them.

By the third round nobody knows which version the client meant. Proofing software puts the file, the comments and the approval in one place.

The tools differ a lot in what they actually proof. Some read print artwork, some only handle video, and some are a toolbar for one website platform.

This ranking is written for freelancers, agencies and in-house teams of 1 to 200 people. We favor tools where a client can leave a comment without creating an account, where the price is findable before a sales call, and where the sign-off is recorded.

We judge setup, the real price, getting your files and comments out, independence from the vendor, and who each tool fits. Fourteen tools made the list.

Wrike Proof, PageProof and Workfront Proof are absent because we could not verify enough current facts about them.

Setup: how fast a client can leave a comment

The test is whether a client can comment within a minute of opening your link. Cage, GoVisually, Ziflow and Pastel let outside reviewers comment or approve without making an account, and that single feature decides whether clients actually use the tool. Tools that force a signup send reviewers back to email. Uploading is quick everywhere.

The slower part is building the workflow: Ziflow limits stages by tier, Filestage sets up reviewer groups, and Approval Studio needs five seats before you begin. We favored tools that a solo person can start on the same afternoon, and we noted where a team has to configure stages, checklists or templates first.

The real price: seats, allowances and tiers

Twelve of the fourteen tools publish a price, but they count different things. Cage charges $8 per user a month, GoVisually starts at $16, ReviewStudio at $15 and Frame.io at $15. Ziflow's first paid step is $199 a month, Approval Studio's is $60 for five users, and MarkUp.io charges $79 for 50 MarkUps rather than for seats. Lytho and Notism show no prices.

Filestage's page lists two price sets and does not say which applies. Check the minimum seat count, the file allowance and any storage cap before you compare monthly totals, because a low headline price with a five-user minimum is not cheap for a two-person studio.

Getting your data out: files, comments and records

Comments and approvals are only useful if you can keep them after you cancel. Pastel offers CSV export even on the free plan, and webhook export arrives on Team. Filestage and Ziflow keep an audit trail of decisions, with Ziflow's lasting 90 days on Standard, a year on Pro and the life of the account on Enterprise. Most vendors do not describe a full export of comment history on the pages we read, so ask before you rely on it.

Treat the approval record as evidence: save a PDF of the final round for each client project yourself rather than trusting the tool to hold it for years.

Independence from the vendor: ownership, hosting and AI training

Where your client's unreleased artwork is stored matters more here than in most software. Ziflow serves EU customers from an EU data center but holds shared tenant data in the United States, and states that customer data is not used to train third-party AI models. GoVisually keeps servers in Australia and the United States. Lytho hosts in the Netherlands.

Frame.io belongs to Adobe, and its privacy link redirects to an Adobe policy, so hosting and training terms could not be confirmed. Pastel's policy says some data may be analyzed with machine learning and does not say whether canvases train models.

Read the data section before you upload embargoed campaigns.

Who it's for: freelancers, agencies and in-house teams

A freelancer needs a cheap seat and frictionless clients, an agency needs workflow stages, and an in-house team needs audit trails and security. Cage, Pastel and Wipster Light serve the freelancer. Ziflow, Filestage and GoVisually cover agencies of 3 to 50 people. Lytho and Ziflow Enterprise serve larger marketing operations.

The format matters as much as team size. Wipster and Frame.io are video-first, Approval Studio is for print and packaging, and Atarim and Pastel are aimed at website feedback.

Pick the tool that proofs the file type you ship most often.

Compared at a glance

#ProductBest forPricingFree optionHQ
1ZiflowAgencies and brand teams of 3 to 50Per seat tiersFree planUnited Kingdom
2FilestageMarketing teams with several approversTiered seats and projectsFree planGermany
3GoVisuallySmall agencies and packaging teamsPer user / monthFree trialNot stated
4Approval StudioPackaging and print production teamsFlat monthlyFree trialUnited States
5ReviewStudioTeams reviewing mixed mediaPer user / monthFree planCanada
6WipsterVideo editors and production studiosPer account / per userFree trialNew Zealand
7Frame.ioFilm and video crews on Adobe toolsPer member / monthFree planUnited States
8CageFreelancers and small client teamsPer user / monthFree planUnited States
9MarkUp.ioWeb teams collecting client feedbackUsage-basedFree trialUnited States
10PastelFreelance web designersPer user tiersFree planCanada
11LythoLarge in-house creative operationsQuote onlyNoneUnited States
12Dropbox ReplayDropbox-based video teamsPer user add-onNoneUnited States
13NotismSmall design teams in GermanyPer project tiersFree planGermany
14AtarimWordPress agenciesCredit-basedFree planUnited Kingdom

The 14 tools, reviewed

How this list is ordered: by our editorial assessment of fit for designers, creators and small to mid-sized creative and marketing teams. Vendors can pay for more visibility; how that works is explained in our disclosure, linked above every ranking. No commission is earned on clicks or purchases, and we do not work as an affiliate.

  1. 1

    #1 Ziflow

    Online proofing for design, video and live websites

    ProofingWorkflowEnterprise-ready

    Why #1: Ziflow leads because one free account already covers design files, video and live sites, and the paid steps stay predictable as a team grows.

    Best for
    Agencies and brand teams of 3 to 50
    Pricing
    Per seat tiers
    Free option
    Free plan
    Headquarters
    United Kingdom
    Key features
    Design, video and live website proofs, Version comparison, Public proof links on Free, Checklists inside the markup view, Workflow stages (1 to 3 by tier)
    Falls short
    The step from the free plan to Standard is a full $199 a month with nothing in between, and Standard allows only two workflow stages and one active template.
    Wrong for
    A solo freelancer who needs more than two users but cannot carry $199 a month.
    Full assessment of Ziflow

    Ziflow earns first place by covering the widest range of file types without forcing a purchase on day one. The free plan allows version comparison and public links, so a freelancer can run a real client round before paying anything.

    Checklists sit inside the markup view, which keeps reviewers on one structure instead of a pile of loose comments. Workflow stages scale from one to three across the tiers, and the audit trail lengthens as you pay more.

    It suits a studio that wants a single place for stills, edits and landing pages.

    Where it falls short

    The step from the free plan to Standard is a full $199 a month with nothing in between, and Standard allows only two workflow stages and one active template. Three stages need Pro.

    ReviewAI is named only in the Enterprise description, so check it before assuming AI checks come with a lower tier.

    Wrong for

    A solo freelancer who needs more than two users but cannot carry $199 a month. A per-user tool such as GoVisually or Cage fits that budget better.

    Visit website

  2. 2

    #2 Filestage

    Review and approval workflow with reviewer groups

    ApprovalsVideo reviewAudit trail

    Why #2: Filestage takes second place with tidy reviewer groups, frame-accurate video comments and an audit trail of each decision, billed in euros.

    Best for
    Marketing teams with several approvers
    Pricing
    Tiered seats and projects
    Free option
    Free plan
    Headquarters
    Germany
    Key features
    Reviewer groups, Version comparison with advanced compare mode, Frame-accurate video comments, Live website feedback, Automations and reminders
    Falls short
    The pricing page lists two sets of paid prices and does not say which one applies, so confirm in writing before you commit.
    Wrong for
    A freelancer who needs more than five files a month and does not want to ask sales for a price.
    Full assessment of Filestage

    Filestage is the pick when the hard part of proofing is people, not files. Reviewers are organized into groups, each decision is logged, and reminders chase whoever is holding up a round.

    Video comments land on exact frames, and live websites can be reviewed alongside stills. Review Agents compare a file with brand guidelines and flag a missing logo, a broken link or an outdated version.

    It lands just behind Ziflow only because its pricing page leaves the buyer guessing.

    Where it falls short

    The pricing page lists two sets of paid prices and does not say which one applies, so confirm in writing before you commit. The free plan allows one active project and five new files a month, which is a trial rather than a working tier.

    Review Agents sit on Business, so Starter customers get no AI feedback.

    Wrong for

    A freelancer who needs more than five files a month and does not want to ask sales for a price. Cage or ReviewStudio publish clearer entry points.

    Visit website

  3. 3

    #3 GoVisually

    Per-user proofing with one-click client approval

    Low entry pricePackagingClient approval

    Why #3: GoVisually ranks third because its per-user price starts at $16 and external reviewers can approve with one click and no account.

    Best for
    Small agencies and packaging teams
    Pricing
    Per user / month
    Free option
    Free trial
    Headquarters
    Not stated
    Key features
    One-click external approval, Approval checklists with notifications, Version control with change tracking, Video and GIF proofing on Pro, Zapier, Slack and Adobe integrations on Pro
    Falls short
    The privacy policy places data servers in Australia and the United States, and no EU hosting option is stated.
    Wrong for
    A company with a strict EU data-residency rule, or a team of ten that outgrows Lite.
    Full assessment of GoVisually

    GoVisually works well for a small team that wants to pay for the seats it uses. A client opens a link and approves without making an account, which removes the usual first-round friction.

    Checklists notify the next person when a step completes, and changes are tracked across versions inside a project. Pro adds video and GIF proofing and the integrations most studios already run.

    A packaging-focused compliance suite exists for label checks, though it is sold by quote.

    Where it falls short

    The privacy policy places data servers in Australia and the United States, and no EU hosting option is stated. Lite stops at five users, 15 active projects and 15 external reviewers, with email-only support.

    The compliance suite has tailored pricing and no public accuracy detail, so treat its claims as unproven until you see a trial.

    Wrong for

    A company with a strict EU data-residency rule, or a team of ten that outgrows Lite. Filestage and Lytho are the places to look for European-side handling.

    Visit website

  4. 4

    #4 Approval Studio

    Proofing that understands packaging and print files

    Print proofingBarcodesColor separations

    Why #4: Approval Studio is the print specialist here, with color separations, barcode reading and an on-screen ruler that general proofing tools skip.

    Best for
    Packaging and print production teams
    Pricing
    Flat monthly
    Free option
    Free trial
    Headquarters
    United States
    Key features
    Color separation support, Four comparison modes on Lite, Barcode reading, On-screen ruler, Website proofing by URL
    Falls short
    Lite and Pro both require five users, so a two-person studio pays for empty seats.
    Wrong for
    A freelancer or a team that reviews web and video only.
    Full assessment of Approval Studio

    Approval Studio is the one to try when the artwork will go on a press or a box. It reads barcodes, shows color separations and offers a ruler on screen, so a reviewer can check a dieline instead of guessing from a screenshot.

    Clients approve without making an account, and pasting a URL covers a quick website check. Staged workflows with automatic notifications start on Pro.

    For regulated packaging it covers ground that screen-first tools leave open.

    Where it falls short

    Lite and Pro both require five users, so a two-person studio pays for empty seats. Lite and Pro hold only 5 GB and Pro XL holds 30 GB, which fills fast with high-resolution artwork.

    AI Assistant and AI Tools are listed with no description of what they do.

    Wrong for

    A freelancer or a team that reviews web and video only. A print-quality ruler does not matter there, and Cage or Pastel cost far less.

    Visit website

  5. 5

    #5 ReviewStudio

    Proofing with markup built for each media type

    Mixed media3D reviewFree guests

    Why #5: ReviewStudio gets fourth place for media-specific markup, including video timelines, documents and 3D GLB models, plus unlimited guests on a free plan.

    Best for
    Teams reviewing mixed media
    Pricing
    Per user / month
    Free option
    Free plan
    Headquarters
    Canada
    Key features
    Video timeline markup, Document markup, 3D GLB model review, Live web proofing by URL capture, Compare and present modes
    Falls short
    Starter allows three active reviews in total and 5 GB, so it works as a trial.
    Wrong for
    A team that wants automated brand checks today.
    Full assessment of ReviewStudio

    ReviewStudio is a good fit for a team whose work does not fit into one file type. Markup is tuned per format, so a video gets a timeline, a document gets page-level notes and a GLB model can be reviewed in 3D.

    Guests are unlimited even on Starter, which is unusual at this price. Pro costs $15 per user a month, and Advanced adds automations, checklists and a reporting dashboard.

    It is a sensible middle choice between hobby tools and enterprise suites.

    Where it falls short

    Starter allows three active reviews in total and 5 GB, so it works as a trial. Advanced needs five users and Enterprise needs twenty.

    No AI review feature is named on the pages we read, and the policy describes servers without naming a host or region.

    Wrong for

    A team that wants automated brand checks today. Ziflow or Filestage name AI review features, and ReviewStudio does not.

    Visit website

  6. 6

    #6 Wipster

    Video review with panels inside your editor

    VideoEditor panelsStakeholder sign-off

    Why #6: Wipster is the video-first option, with real-time frame comments, side-by-side versions and review panels inside Final Cut Pro and Premiere.

    Best for
    Video editors and production studios
    Pricing
    Per account / per user
    Free option
    Free trial
    Headquarters
    New Zealand
    Key features
    Real-time frame-accurate comments, Reviewers need no paid account, Side-by-side version comparison, Staged approvals with audit trail, Review Panel in Final Cut Pro and Premiere
    Falls short
    There is no free plan and the trial length is not stated.
    Wrong for
    A design agency whose proofs are mostly stills, PDFs and web pages.
    Full assessment of Wipster

    Wipster suits editors who live in a timeline. Comments appear to other reviewers in real time and attach to exact frames, and a panel inside Final Cut Pro or Premiere brings those notes into the edit.

    Reviewers do not need a paid account, and staged approvals leave a record of who signed off. Light costs under $10 a month for one person, which makes it the cheapest serious video proofing here.

    It ranks sixth because it handles little beyond video.

    Where it falls short

    There is no free plan and the trial length is not stated. Light holds about 50 GB and Team starts at 250 GB, which raw video can exceed quickly.

    WipAI Automated Media Review appears in the navigation with no description, so its scope is unknown.

    Wrong for

    A design agency whose proofs are mostly stills, PDFs and web pages. Ziflow, Filestage or GoVisually cover those formats better.

    Visit website

  7. 7

    #7 Frame.io

    Adobe's video review and media hub

    Video reviewAdobeCamera to Cloud

    Why #7: Frame.io is the Adobe-owned incumbent for video review, with frame-accurate comments, camera-to-cloud upload and enterprise security controls.

    Best for
    Film and video crews on Adobe tools
    Pricing
    Per member / month
    Free option
    Free plan
    Headquarters
    United States
    Key features
    Frame-accurate comments, Video, image and document review, Collections with custom metadata, Tasks and milestones, Mounted Storage on paid tiers
    Falls short
    Free stops at two members and two projects, and Pro stops at five members.
    Wrong for
    A brand team proofing packaging or a magazine layout.
    Full assessment of Frame.io

    Frame.io is built for productions that shoot, edit and review in one pipeline. Comments sit on exact frames, collections carry custom metadata, and Camera to Cloud sends footage from set before the crew packs up.

    Mounted Storage streams remote files to a desktop on paid tiers. Enterprise adds forensic watermarking, DRM and single sign-on.

    It is held out of the top three because it is a major vendor and because still-image and print proofing is not its center.

    Where it falls short

    Free stops at two members and two projects, and Pro stops at five members. AI features are linked but not described on the pages we read.

    The privacy link redirects to an Adobe policy, so training use, hosting region and certifications could not be confirmed. No color separation or barcode checks are listed.

    Wrong for

    A brand team proofing packaging or a magazine layout. Approval Studio handles print checks, and Frame.io does not list them.

    Visit website

  8. 8

    #8 Cage

    Low-cost annotation for files and client projects

    Budget150+ formatsClient presentations

    Why #8: Cage is the cheapest per-seat tool in this list at $8 a user, with annotations on more than 150 formats and a free plan for one person.

    Best for
    Freelancers and small client teams
    Pricing
    Per user / month
    Free option
    Free plan
    Headquarters
    United States
    Key features
    Annotation on images, video, audio and PDFs, More than 150 other formats, Multi-frame video notes, Date- and time-stamped approvals, Project hub with tasks and milestones
    Falls short
    No AI feature is named, so every check stays manual.
    Wrong for
    A company with a security review that wants certifications on file.
    Full assessment of Cage

    Cage is where a freelancer should start when the budget is tight. At $8 per user a month, Standard is the lowest published seat price here, and even the free plan allows unlimited reviewers.

    Video notes can span more than one frame, approvals carry a date and time stamp, and the project hub keeps tasks, files and discussions together. Client presentations can be shared by password, publicly or by direct send.

    It trails the leaders on automation and compliance.

    Where it falls short

    No AI feature is named, so every check stays manual. The privacy policy is dated May 2018 and no SOC 2, ISO 27001 or GDPR certification is stated.

    Standard and Professional cover up to 25 people, and larger teams must request a quote.

    Wrong for

    A company with a security review that wants certifications on file. Ziflow lists SOC 2 Type 2 and ISO 27001:2022 in its privacy policy.

    Visit website

  9. 9

    #9 MarkUp.io

    Pin comments straight onto sites, images and files

    Web feedbackUnlimited usersAllowance pricing

    Why #9: MarkUp.io prices by monthly MarkUp allowance instead of seats, so unlimited users can comment on pages, images, video and PDFs.

    Best for
    Web teams collecting client feedback
    Pricing
    Usage-based
    Free option
    Free trial
    Headquarters
    United States
    Key features
    Pinned comments on elements, Video comments pinned to timestamps, Drawing and highlight tools, PDF review with page flags, Unlimited users on Pro
    Falls short
    Pro stops at 50, 75 or 100 MarkUps a month, which a busy agency can use in a week.
    Wrong for
    An agency running dozens of concurrent reviews.
    Full assessment of MarkUp.io

    MarkUp.io fits a team where many people comment but few projects run at once. Pricing counts MarkUps rather than seats, so a client's whole department can leave notes without raising the bill.

    Pinned comments stay attached to the exact element on a site or image, and video comments are fixed to timestamps. Pro includes unlimited users and Google or Microsoft sign-on.

    A busy agency will notice the allowance, which is why it sits in the middle of the ranking.

    Where it falls short

    Pro stops at 50, 75 or 100 MarkUps a month, which a busy agency can use in a week. The jump from Pro at $79 to Business at $499 is steep, and branding and a vanity domain sit behind it.

    There is no free plan and no AI feature is named, only a 14-day trial.

    Wrong for

    An agency running dozens of concurrent reviews. A flat per-user tool such as Cage or GoVisually will cost less at that volume.

    Visit website

  10. 10

    #10 Pastel

    Visual feedback for live sites, ads and PDFs

    Web feedbackFreelancersGuest comments

    Why #10: Pastel suits freelancers who collect feedback on live Webflow and Shopify sites, with guest commenting and a switch that freezes feedback between rounds.

    Best for
    Freelance web designers
    Pricing
    Per user tiers
    Free option
    Free plan
    Headquarters
    Canada
    Key features
    Comments on live Webflow and Shopify sites, Landing page, ad, PDF and video review, Guest commenting without an account, Pause Comments switch, Feedback deadlines with reminders
    Falls short
    Pro stops at two users and three canvases, and Team starts at five users.
    Wrong for
    A packaging or print team, or a company that needs a SOC 2 report on a small plan.
    Full assessment of Pastel

    Pastel is made for the designer who sends a staging link and wants clean answers by Friday. Guests comment without an account, a Pause Comments switch freezes input between revision rounds, and deadlines close a round and send reminders.

    It works on live Webflow and Shopify sites, and on ads, PDFs, videos and wireframes. The free plan includes CSV export.

    It sits tenth because the paid tiers are small and its coverage of formal approval is light.

    Where it falls short

    Pro stops at two users and three canvases, and Team starts at five users. Print proofing is not covered: no color separation, barcode or packaging checks are named.

    The SOC 2 report is available only with the $450 monthly Enterprise tier, and the policy does not say whether canvases train models.

    Wrong for

    A packaging or print team, or a company that needs a SOC 2 report on a small plan. Approval Studio or Ziflow suit them better.

    Visit website

  11. 11

    #11 Lytho

    Creative workflow suite with built-in reviews

    SuiteAsset libraryEnterprise

    Why #11: Lytho wraps proofing inside a larger workflow and asset-management suite, with governed libraries and structured request intake, sold only by quote.

    Best for
    Large in-house creative operations
    Pricing
    Quote only
    Free option
    None
    Headquarters
    United States
    Key features
    Structured intake forms, One-click approvals with visible status, Governed digital asset library, Expiry dates and rights management, AI Teammates compliance add-on
    Falls short
    No prices are published, so cost cannot be compared before a sales call.
    Wrong for
    A freelancer or three-person studio that only wants to collect comments on a draft.
    Full assessment of Lytho

    Lytho is for an in-house team that wants requests, reviews and the finished asset library under one roof. Intake forms feed a queue, approvals show their status to everyone involved, and the library tracks expiry dates and usage rights.

    An AI add-on scans content at workflow stages for compliance, though it costs extra. Servers are in the Netherlands and personal data is processed inside the EEA where possible.

    It ranks low here only because proofing is a module, not the product.

    Where it falls short

    No prices are published, so cost cannot be compared before a sales call. Proofing is one module inside a larger suite, which means paying for workflow and asset management you may not use.

    The first-listed office is in North Carolina, with a second in Amsterdam.

    Wrong for

    A freelancer or three-person studio that only wants to collect comments on a draft. The suite is heavy for that, and Cage or Pastel are lighter.

    Visit website

  12. 12

    #12 Dropbox Replay

    Video and audio review add-on for Dropbox

    VideoAudioDropbox add-on

    Why #12: Dropbox Replay is a video and audio review add-on for teams already paying for Dropbox, with uploads of up to 150 GB per file.

    Best for
    Dropbox-based video teams
    Pricing
    Per user add-on
    Free option
    None
    Headquarters
    United States
    Key features
    Video and audio comments, Resolvable comments, Final sign-off on edits, 150 GB per file, Audio or video up to 12 hours
    Falls short
    The add-on price sits on top of a Dropbox plan, so the total is higher than the list price.
    Wrong for
    A team that does not use Dropbox, or one that reviews design files and web pages.
    Full assessment of Dropbox Replay

    Dropbox Replay makes sense when footage and audio already live in Dropbox. Comments can be resolved as an editor works through them, and the final edit gets a sign-off.

    File limits are generous: up to 150 GB per file, and audio or video up to 12 hours. The euro add-on price is modest.

    It sits near the bottom because it does only video and audio review and leans on a separate subscription.

    Where it falls short

    The add-on price sits on top of a Dropbox plan, so the total is higher than the list price. It is unavailable on the Family plan, and no free trial is described on the page.

    Uploads count toward the account's Dropbox storage, and the page names no contracting entity for each region.

    Wrong for

    A team that does not use Dropbox, or one that reviews design files and web pages. Ziflow or Filestage cover those without a storage subscription.

    Visit website

  13. 13

    #13 Notism

    Sketch notes on designs and video

    Sketch notesPrototypesHamburg

    Why #13: Notism lets teams sketch notes directly on designs and video and turn static screens into clickable prototypes, but paid prices are not public.

    Best for
    Small design teams in Germany
    Pricing
    Per project tiers
    Free option
    Free plan
    Headquarters
    Germany
    Key features
    Notes and sketches drawn on designs, Comments on the video timeline, Clickable prototypes from static screens, Versions, Assigned to-dos with notifications
    Falls short
    The pricing page showed placeholders instead of amounts, so no paid price can be confirmed.
    Wrong for
    A team that needs formal staged approvals, audit trails or a published price before talking to sales.
    Full assessment of Notism

    Notism is a friendly tool for drawing straight onto a design or a cut and handing feedback back as to-dos. Video comments tie to a moment on the timeline, and static web or mobile screens can be turned into clickable prototypes.

    Versions and notifications keep revisions organized. It is a Hamburg company, and multi-year billing discounts are stated.

    Missing prices and workflow depth keep it near the bottom.

    Where it falls short

    The pricing page showed placeholders instead of amounts, so no paid price can be confirmed. The free plan is one project with limited features and no support.

    No review automation, approval workflow or AI check is described, and the privacy page does not address AI training.

    Wrong for

    A team that needs formal staged approvals, audit trails or a published price before talking to sales. Filestage or Ziflow fit those needs.

    Visit website

  14. 14

    #14 Atarim

    Feedback toolbar for WordPress site projects

    WordPressCreditsSite feedback

    Why #14: Atarim is a WordPress-oriented feedback toolbar, but its credit pricing and AI-agency homepage make it a narrow pick for proofing.

    Best for
    WordPress agencies
    Pricing
    Credit-based
    Free option
    Free plan
    Headquarters
    United Kingdom
    Key features
    WordPress feedback toolbar, 200 one-time credits on Free, 5,000 monthly credits on Pro, Up to 1,000 projects on Pro, 100 seats on Pro
    Falls short
    Pricing runs on credits, so monthly usage must be watched when AI agents run.
    Wrong for
    Anyone proofing images, video or print artwork, or anyone who wants flat monthly pricing without watching a credit balance.
    Full assessment of Atarim

    Atarim is worth a look only if your work is WordPress sites. It puts a feedback toolbar on pages so clients can comment where they see a problem.

    Pro allows up to 1,000 projects and 100 seats for $67 a month. Enterprise lists SOC 2, GDPR, SSO and SAML.

    It ranks last because creative proofing for images, video and print is outside its focus.

    Where it falls short

    Pricing runs on credits, so monthly usage must be watched when AI agents run. The homepage leads with an AI agency offer and the feedback toolbar sits behind it.

    The free plan is a one-off allowance, so it cannot cover ongoing proofing. The FAQ also gives two different credit estimates.

    Wrong for

    Anyone proofing images, video or print artwork, or anyone who wants flat monthly pricing without watching a credit balance. Those buyers should choose Ziflow, Filestage or Wipster.

    Visit website

What the data says about this market

Of the fourteen tools we ranked, eight offer a free plan, four offer only a free trial and two offer neither. Free plans are tight: Ziflow stops at two users and 2 GB, Frame.io at two members, Cage at one user and one project, and Pastel at one user and one canvas. They work for a trial or a single freelancer, rarely for a team. Twelve of the fourteen publish a price.

Lytho is quote-only and Notism shows no amounts. Paid entry points range from $8 per user a month at Cage to $199 a month at Ziflow and Filestage.

Six of the fourteen are headquartered in the United States, two each in the United Kingdom, Germany and Canada, and one in New Zealand. GoVisually is run by an Australian company, which is why we list its country as not stated. The market splits by file type more than by country: Wipster, Frame.io and Dropbox Replay are video-first, Approval Studio is print-first, and Atarim and Pastel are website-first. Source for the counts: our own list, with each tool's pricing, hosting and company pages opened in November 2026.

AI review is arriving but is unevenly documented. Ziflow's ReviewAI and Filestage's Review Agents check files against brand rules, and both sit on upper tiers. GoVisually sells a quoted label-compliance suite, and Lytho sells an AI add-on. Cage, ReviewStudio, MarkUp.io and Notism name no AI feature on the pages we read.

Treat AI claims as roadmap items until a trial shows what is flagged, because the vendors we checked give little detail on accuracy.

How to choose

1. Name the file type you proof most

Start with the format, not the feature list. If most of your rounds are video, shortlist Wipster, Frame.io or Dropbox Replay. If they are packaging or print artwork, Approval Studio is the only tool here that lists barcode reading, color separations and an on-screen ruler. For live websites, look at Pastel, MarkUp.io, Atarim or Ziflow, which also proofs sites.

If you ship a mix, Ziflow, Filestage and ReviewStudio cover stills, video and web in one place. Write down the three formats you send each month and cross off any tool that cannot open them.

2. Count reviewers and seats before you read prices

The monthly price means little until you know who comments and who manages. Tools that charge per seat, such as Cage and GoVisually, favor many outside reviewers and few internal users. MarkUp.io charges by allowance, which favors many commenters on few projects. Check minimums too: Approval Studio needs five users on its first two tiers, and ReviewStudio's Advanced tier needs five as well.

A two-person studio should cross those off at once. Ask whether external reviewers are free, because that decides your real cost.

3. Run one live client round on a trial

Test with a real client, not a sample file. Send a link to someone who has never used the tool and see whether they comment without help. Time how long it takes you to collect, resolve and approve one round. Then check the three things vendors hide: the storage cap, how long the approval record is kept, and where files are hosted.

Export the comments before you decide. If the vendor's answer on any of these is vague, treat that as the answer.

Frequently asked questions

What is the best creative proofing software in 2026?

Ziflow ranks first because its free plan already covers design files, video and live websites, with version comparison and public links, and the paid tiers add stages and an audit trail in clear steps. Filestage is the better pick when you have several approvers and want reviewer groups. GoVisually is better for a small agency that wants a low per-user price and one-click client approval.

What is creative proofing software?

It is a review platform where reviewers comment directly on artwork, video, documents or web pages, and approvers sign off on a specific version. Comments are pinned to the exact spot, versions can be compared, and the approval is recorded. It replaces email threads and screenshots with one place that shows what changed and who agreed.

Is there free creative proofing software?

Yes, eight of the fourteen tools have a free plan: Ziflow, Filestage, Frame.io, Cage, Pastel, ReviewStudio, Notism and Atarim. The limits are real. Ziflow allows two users and 2 GB, Cage one user and one project, and Filestage one active project with five new files a month.

Free plans suit a single freelancer or a trial.

Which tool is cheapest for a freelancer?

Cage is the cheapest published seat at $8 per user a month, and its free plan allows one user with unlimited reviewers. Wipster Light is $9.95 a month billed annually for one person and is the better choice for video. Pastel's free plan allows one user and one canvas, which suits occasional website feedback.

Which tools handle print and packaging proofs?

Approval Studio lists color separations, barcode reading and an on-screen ruler, and starts at $60 a month with a five-user minimum. GoVisually sells a label-compliance suite by quote for packaging. Most others in this ranking focus on screens, video and web pages and do not list print checks.

Can clients review without creating an account?

Several tools allow it. GoVisually offers one-click external approval, Approval Studio and Wipster let reviewers work without an account, Pastel supports guest commenting, and Ziflow offers public proof links on its free plan. Always test with a real client, because the exact flow differs and some features sit on paid tiers.

Which proofing tool is best for video review?

Wipster is the specialist for video, with real-time frame-accurate comments and panels inside Final Cut Pro and Premiere. Frame.io, an Adobe product, adds Camera to Cloud and enterprise controls. Dropbox Replay suits teams already on Dropbox, with uploads up to 150 GB per file.

Filestage and Ziflow also handle video alongside other formats.

Does proofing software use AI to check files?

Some do. Ziflow's ReviewAI checks checklist items and brand standards on its Enterprise tier, and Filestage's Review Agents check files against brand guidelines on Business. GoVisually and Lytho sell compliance add-ons.

Cage, ReviewStudio, MarkUp.io and Notism name no AI feature on the pages we read, so their checks stay manual.

Where is my data stored?

It varies. Ziflow serves EU customers from an EU data center but keeps shared tenant data in the United States. GoVisually lists servers in Australia and the United States, Lytho hosts in the Netherlands, and Cage processes data in the United States.

Frame.io's hosting could not be confirmed because its privacy link goes to an Adobe policy.

How long are approval records kept?

Only Ziflow states this clearly: its audit trail lasts 90 days on Standard, one year on Pro and the life of the account on Enterprise. Filestage and Wipster describe audit trails or recorded sign-off without a stated retention period. Save a PDF of the final approved round for each client job yourself.

When should a team choose a suite like Lytho over a proofing tool?

Choose a suite when requests, reviews and the finished asset library need to live under one governed system, as in a large in-house creative operation. Lytho is quote-only and adds expiry dates and rights management. A small studio that only needs comments and sign-off will pay for features it does not use and is better served by Cage, Ziflow or GoVisually.